RealityHackerOpen in RealityHacker ⇢
Science · AI in Mathematics · published 2026-11-17T00:00:00+00:00 · via Scientific American

The Existence of Infinitesimals: A Mathematical Paradox That Shaped Calculus

Image via Scientific American
Image via Scientific American

Infinitesimals—quantities infinitely close to zero yet not quite zero—have been foundational to calculus since its inception by Newton and Leibniz, despite deep philosophical skepticism. Ancient mathematicians like Archimedes questioned their existence, and later thinkers such as George Berkeley criticized them as logically inconsistent, arguing they were neither finite nor truly infinitesimal. Even though these concepts were used to derive critical results in physics and mathematics, many early practitioners, including Newton, avoided publishing with them directly, opting for more conventional methods.

Expanded Detail

The debate over infinitesimals—quantities infinitely close to zero but not equal to it—has spanned centuries, beginning with Archimedes’ early conceptualization in ancient Greece and persisting through the foundational work of Newton and Leibniz in the 17th century. Despite their instrumental role in developing calculus, these quantities faced deep skepticism: philosopher George Berkeley famously dismissed them in 1734 as “the ghosts of departed quantities,” highlighting their logical ambiguity. In response, 19th-century mathematician Karl Weierstrass replaced infinitesimals with the rigorous epsilon-delta framework, which became standard in mathematical education despite its complexity. However, the intuitive power of infinitesimals persisted in applied mathematics and physics. This tension culminated in the 1960s when Abraham Robinson, building on Kurt Gödel’s model theory, formalized infinitesimals through non-standard analysis. Using Gödel’s completeness and compactness theorems, Robinson demonstrated that a larger mathematical universe—non-standard analysis—could contain infinitesimal numbers while preserving consistency with standard real-number arithmetic. This development validated infinitesimals not as philosophical curiosities but as mathematically coherent entities. The key actors include historical figures like Newton and Leibniz, who used infinitesimals pragmatically without full formal justification; Berkeley, who challenged their logic; Weierstrass, who sought rigor through limits; and Robinson, who reconciled intuition with formalism. What remains unresolved is the extent to which non-standard analysis will supplant traditional calculus in education and research, despite its conceptual elegance.

Context

The revival of infinitesimals through Robinson’s work could influence how mathematics is taught and applied, particularly in fields requiring intuitive reasoning about continuous change—such as physics, engineering, and AI-driven modeling. While the epsilon-delta approach remains dominant in academic curricula, non-standard analysis may gain traction in computational contexts where intuitive handling of limits is advantageous. This shift may affect educational institutions, textbook publishers, and software developers creating mathematically grounded tools. A comparable precedent exists in the 20th-century adoption of category theory: initially seen as abstract and esoteric, it eventually influenced computer science and quantum physics. However, widespread integration of infinitesimals into mainstream mathematics remains uncertain. The impact may be most pronounced in AI and machine learning, where gradient-based methods rely on infinitesimal changes—non-standard analysis could offer new ways to formalize these processes. What to watch for is whether institutions begin revising curricula or if computational frameworks adopt non-standard models for greater precision. These developments could emerge gradually, as the mathematical community weighs conceptual clarity against pedagogical tradition.

Expanded detail and Context are AI-generated analysis; the linked article remains the authoritative source.
Read the full article at Scientific American →
Related stories
The Historic Debate Over Calculus: Newton vs. Leibniz · AI in Mathematics
This summary is Al-enhanced to contain extended analysis and broader social context. The original is {NAME); the linked article is the authoritative source. Original headline: “Infinitesimals are essential to calculus. But are they even real?.” Browse more stories.